Dale
Home
Journal Pages
 
Learning:
The Journey of a Lifetime
or
A Cloud Chamber of the Mind
To Dos Lists
Previous Page
Links to Notebook Pages:
 

Saturday November 18, 2006 8:20 am Lethbridge Sunrise 7:48 Sunset 17:45 Hours of daylight: 8:57

A. Morning Musings

8:20 am It is +2 C at the moment with a high of +9 C forecast.

I am up late, but feeling alert and refreshed. I am pleased with my latest efforts at reviewing and making notes for "Fearless Symmetry". I will begin the day by completing these review notes which emphasize the concepts and provide examples of the ideas.

From rear window
South patio
Both images taken at 12:50 PM

B. Plan

Immediate    
Health Walk & exercise 1 hr
Mathematics Make notes for "Fearless Symmetry" chap 8: Galois groups 3 hr
History Continue reading & making notes for "Citizens" 1 hr
GO Play 3 games of 9x9 GO++; Solve problems from Graded GO Problems for Beginners 1 hr
Literature Begin reading "Disgrace" by Coetze 1 hr
Later    
Chores Investigate water softeners for home  
Technology Read manual for cell phone  
  Make notes for chap. 4 of "Switching to the Mac"  
  Begin reading "iPhoto"  
 

digital photography - learn about using the various manual settings

 
Philosophy Read "The Art of Living" by Epictetus  
Mathematics Larson "Calculus"  
  Read "Symmetry" by Hermann Weyl  
  Read "The Computational Beauty of Nature" Chap 3  
  Gardner "The Colossal Book of Short Puzzles"  
History Watson "Ideas"  
Model Trains Build oil refinery diorama: add ground cover  
  Assemble second oil platform kit  
  Assembly of CN 5930, an SD40-2 with a NAFTA logo  
Puzzles The Orange Puzzle Cube: puzzle #9  

C. Actual/Notes

Mathematics 20

November 18

Mathematics Chronology

8:40 am

This is a continuation of yesterday's note making while reviewing chapters 1 - 8 of "Fearless Symmetry".

The book is divided into three main parts:

  • Part One. Algebraic Preliminaries (chaps. 1 - 7)
  • Part Two. Galois Theory and Representations (chaps. 8 - 16)
  • Part Three. Reciprocity Laws (chaps. 17 - 23)

I am thoroughly enjoying this book. It is quite different than other books I have read in the last couple of years. I would categorize these books as follows:

  • books that describe how to "do" certain things (e.g. textbooks)
  • books on the history of mathematics
  • general books on mathematics, but no "real" mathematics
  • books that focus on the ideas and concepts of mathematics (this book!)
"Fearless Symmetry" is largely about terminology (i.e. concepts) and notation.

Let me try to review the previous seven chapters that constitute Part One:

Chapter
Terminology (concepts)
Description
Notation
Part One Algebraic Preliminaries    
1
Representations    
set A set is a collection of things, often called the elements of the set. {a, b, c}

one-to-one correspondence

A one-to-one correspondence from a set A to set B is a rule that associates to each element in A exactly one element in B, in such a way that each element in B gets used exactly once, and for exactly one element in A.

standard object This is an object that we know quite a bit about.  
function A function from a set A to a set B is a rule that assigns to each element in A an element of B.  
morphism A morphism is a function from A to B that captures at least part of the essential nature of the set A in its image in B.  
representation

A representation is a morphism (i.e. a function) from a source object to a standard target object.

If A represents B, we have three things: two objects, A and B, which in this context will be sets, and the relation between them, which will be a morphism. When A and B have some additional "structure" (e.g. they are finite sets, or ordered sets, or ...) and we restrict the possible morphisms from A to B to have something to do with that structure.

 
 

Example:

Let A be the set {red, blue, yellow, pink}.

Let B be the standard object {1, 2, 3, 4}. Let f be the following rule: red is associated with 1, blue is associated with 2, yellow is associated with 3 and pink is associated with 4. f is a morphism because because this rule is capturing something about the number of elements in A. Therefore we may consider f to be a representation of A.

2
Groups    
group

A group G is a set with a composition defined on pairs of elements such that :

1. There is a neutral element e in G, so that no matter what element in the group is substituted for x. e is sometimes called the identity element.

2. For any element x of G, there is some element y in G so that . That is, every element has an inverse element.

3. For any three elements, x, y, and z in G, we have . This is called the associativity of the composition. Each group has its own law of composition. It can be whatever we define it to be (e.g. addition, multiplication, rotation, ...).

 
  group law If G is a group, the group law is the rule that tells how to combine two elements in the group to get the third.
 

discrete groups

There is no smooth path from one element to another. (e.g. the integers under addition, permutation groups)  
  continuous groups There are infinitismal differences between elements.  
 
Lie groups
Pronounced "Lee", named after the Norwegian mathematician Sophus Lie who studied them. (e.g. rigid motions in space, rotations of a circle, rotations of a sphere, set of real numbers under addition)  
 

Examples:

Consider the set Z of all the integers (positive, negative and zero). Z is an infinite set. Let the group law be familiar addition. Then Z under this group law is a group.

Consider the set of three rotations of 60, 120 and 180 degrees of an equilateral triangle. The rotations constitute the group law. The elements of the group are the three positions (i.e. orientations) of the triangle.

Groups are used to describe various types of symmetries.

3
Permutations    
  permutation A permutation is a reordering of a set of elements. It is a function that assigns to each element of the set another element of the set such that it is a one-to-one correspondence. The function gives the rule for assigning each element.
  group of permutations The collection of all possible permutation functions for a given set A forms a group. Notice that if A has n elements then has n! elements. That is, there are n! different reorderings of n elements.
  identity permutation This is the function that leaves every element in the same position.
  inverse permutation This is the function that returns every element to its previous position. Let be a permutation of a set A. Then the inverse if and only if .
  cycle decomposition A particular permutation can be expressed as a series of cycles. For example, one such permutation of A = {a, b, c, d, e} may be a -> d -> a and b_> c -> e -> f-> c.
4
Modular Arithmetic Modular arithmetic is of fundamental importance in all of number theory.  
  conguence Congruence is a binary relation between two numbers similar to equality. Two numbers are said to be congruent modulo n if they have the same remainder when divided by n.
  modulus The number n that is the divisor is called the modulus of the congruence.  
  integer An integer is a whole number - positive, negative or zero  
  prime number A prime number is a positive integer greater than 1 that has no positive divisors except itself and 1. A negative number is also called prime if its absolute value is prime.  
  field

A field is a number system where we can divide by anything nonzero. The integers modulo p (where p is a prime) are a field under addition and multiplication. We say that is a finite field with p elements. We also say that is a number system with characteristic p. Note that does not contain fractions.

is a group under addition.

If we delete the number 0 from , we have a new set of p - 1 elements that is a group under multiplication. The new set is symbolized as "eff-pea-cross" : .

5
Complex Numbers    
  real number Any number that can be expressed as a decimal, either terminating or repeating. R
  complex number A number of the form a + bi where a and b are real numbers. a + bi
  complex conjugate A number of the form a - bi where a and b are real numbers. a - bi
  set of all complex numbers   C
  Theorem Let be a polynomial whose coefficients are any complex numbers. Then the equation = 0 has solutions in C.  
  algebraic closure The field C is closed under algebraic (i.e. addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, and the taking of roots) operations. This is a restatement of the previous theorem.  
       
6
Equations and Varieties One of the main problems in number theory is finding and understanding all solutions of Z-equations.  
  rational number Any number that can be expressed at the ratio of two integers.  
  irrational number Any number that is not rational.  
  set of all rational numbers   Q
  Z-equation Also called a Diophantine equation.  
  set of all integers   Z
  set of integers modulo p  
  variety

The variety S defined by a Z-equation (or a system of Z-equations) is the function that assigns to any number system A the set of solutions S(A) of the equation.

Many different systems of equations can define the same variety S.

S(A)
  Fermat's Last Theorem

For any positive integer n, let the variety be defined by . Then if n > 2, contains only solutions where one or more of the variables is 0.

It is easier to study . Then some information about (the solution set we are really interested in) can be derived from the preceding three sets using advanced theorems from number theory and algebraic geometry.

 
  roots of a polynomial If is a polynomial, the roots of are those numbers c so that .  
7
Quadratic Reciprocity    
  Legendre symbol  
  Quadratic Recirocity  

Suppose that p and q are odd primes.

1.

2.

3. If , then .

4. If p or q or both , then .

Part Two Galois Theory and Representations    
8
Galois Theory    
  algebraic numbers A complex number is algebraic if it is the root of some Z-polynomial.  
  set of all algebraic numbers

That subset of C which consists of all the equations = 0 where is a polynomial with integer coeficients. It can be shown that is a field. Note that i is an algebraic number (it is the solution to the equation ).

Examples:

All the integers. (they are solutions for the polynomial equation x - n = 0 ).

All rational numbers. (they are solutions for the polynomial equation bx - a = 0 ).

nth roots of every fraction. ( they are solutions for the equation .

  algebraically closed field

It can be shown that the sum, difference, product and quotient of any two algebraic numbers will also be an algebraic number.

p is not in . (This is difficult to prove.)

It can be difficult to prove whether a particular number is or is not in .

There are lots of algebraic numbers and they are connected in many complicated ways.

 
  absolute Galois group

1. is the set of all complex numbers that can appear as roots of Z-polynomials.

2. The absolute Galois group G is made up of all permutations g of that preserve addition and multiplication.

3. If g is any element of G and f(x) is any Z-polynomial, then as g acts as a permutation of , it permutes the roots of f(x). It never maps some root of f(x) to a nonroot of f(x).

4. G has infinitely many elements.

5. There is only one element of G, other than the neutral element e, for which we can give a complete description. This element is called c, the complex conjugate. No other element of G an be written down explicitly.

6. Any element g of G can be partially described by taking a Z-polynomial f(x), listing its roots and telling what permutation of these algebraic numbers occurs when we apply g.

7. Zorn's Lemma plus some advanced algebra can be used to piece together the partial descriptions of item 6 to get elements of G. That is how we know that G is infinite.

G
  Zorn's Lemma Allows us to compress the process of doing infinitely many things in a short amount of time, so that we can still have time left over.  
  symmetry

A symmetry is a function that preserves what we feel is important about an object.

Each g in the Galois group G is a symmetry of because it preserves the operations that concern us in algebra, namely, addition and multiplication.

 
       
 

Whew! But the above set of notes is a major step forward for me. I do not yet feel that I understand what a Galois group is or why it is important, but I do understand that it is a very important concept in modern algebra. I continue to be fascinated by "Fearless Symmetry". It is the first book that I have seen that focuses on the concepts rather than on being able to prove theorems or solve problems.

I have conducted a brief google of modern algebra textbooks and have identified two, which happen to be in the university library. Both are written by Joseph Rotman. One is called Advanced Modern Algebra and the second is called Theory of Groups. I want to have a look at them and see if they look accessible.

12:45 PM

D. Reflection