This is a book with superb photographs and illustrations as well as an incisive text. My goal here is to capture a number of quotes, many with an additional comment by myself.

Introduction

"For some, it [Zen] represents the core of the Buddhist path, free from all the cultural and intellectual trappings that can easily block and sidetrack people in their quest for spiritual growth." [p. 7]

I have just googled "religion" and here is a phrase from Wikipedia: "A religion is a set of common beliefs and practices generally held by a group of people ... ". This helped me, as I have always included the concept of God in my definition of religion. Thus I was confused to see Buddhism recognized as a religion when it does not have the worship of God(s) as part of its teachings. Back to the quote. I have a definite preference for approaches that are free from cultural trappings, although I do prefer a strong intellectual component. I am not a fan of blind belief.

"For others, it is a fashionable aesthetic experience with its emphasis on natural harmony and beauty ..." [p. 7]

I like phrases like "natural harmony and beauty", but I have a dislike for "fashionable".

"... for the true Zen experience in not to be limited by individual perceptions that are based on incomplete judgements arising from an untrained ego-mind." [p. 7]

Hmmm. "limited by individual perceptions" - there is value in hearing from others with more experience than oneself. That is what most books provide. Engaging in a discussion or debate with someone else is also of value. But the phrase "incomplete judgements" is potentially problematic as it seems to imply that one should strive for a "complete judgement". I prefer the state of always being open to revision. Finally, "untrained ego-mind", seems to suggest a dichotomy between untrained and trained. I lean toward a continuum with many shades of grey.

And all of the above is based on only the first paragraph in the book. But Hodge was been incredibly successful in triggering a number of thoughts in my mind. That is, in my view, the mark of a good author.

"It is supremely ironic that a form of Buddhism that devalued the use of words, through its emphasis on direct experience, should have given rise to so much literature." [p. 7]

A sense of irony and humor is essential in all things, even model trains.

"Some background reading is vital, in order to equip the reader with the necessary knowledge of the the basic tenets of Buddhism upon which Zen relies, but soon books should be laid aside in favor of the meditation cushion." [p. 7]

I agree with the idea of "some background reading" but am open to a variety of such approaches. I remain unconvinced about the value of meditation. Perhaps I will change my mind after reading this book.

"Unfortunately, the form is often a lifeless shell from which the living essence has long since faded. So I believe it is dangerous for beginners to become too obsessed with the formalities of Zen practice ..." [p. 8]

This applies not only to beginners but to us all, and not only in religious practice, but in all forms of human endeavor.

"Zen Buddhism should involve a deep understanding of loving kindness and compassion." [p. 9]

Not only Zen Buddhism, but all forms of human thought and behavior.

I have finished reading the Introduction, which is only 4 pages. These 4 pages include 3 photographs, two of nature. The text has triggered a number of immediate thoughts. A great beginning to the book.

I like making notes like this. I will continue to do this with some of the other chapters. Although I began these "green boxes" as a form of book review, I now see that I will sometimes want to only focus on a specific chapter, at least when it is a non-fiction book.

Perhaps I am more receptive to this book this morning. There has been a fresh snowfall overnight, with the temperatures very cold the snow is dry and light, and since there is also a noticeable breeze, the drifts have a soft smooth contour shape with no sharp edges. Very calming, peaceful, and beautiful. Japan may have its rock gardens, but we both have snow. Perhaps the value of snow has been underestimated in both countries. Norway appreciates snow. I am thinking of Peter Hoeg's novel, "Smilla's Sense of Snow".

Tags: non-fiction, Buddhism, religion, philosophy, history.