Learning: The Journey of a Lifetime

Journals as an Aid to Learning

History

hist4

An Example of a "Learning Process" Journal (using the 2 colored box format)

 
October 27, 2004

Book: Hegemony or Suvival: America's Quest for Global Dominance.

Source: New York: Henry Holt, 2003.

9:40 am Wednesday. I plan to spend two solid hours on this book this morning.

Book: Hegemony or Survival: America's Quest for Global Dominance.

Chapter 5 The Iraq Connection [p. 109 - 143]

What is the main idea of this chapter?

  • the events of 9-11 provided the reactionary sectors of the Republican administration with an opportunity to pursue long-standing goals with greater intensity.

Structure of the chapter:

  • The Script: International
  • The Script: Domestic
  • Insignificant Risks
  • The Wild Men in the Wings
  • Democracy and Human Rights
  • Liberation From Tyranny: Constructive Solutions

The Script: International

  • Angola: South Africa, with US support, was primarily responsible for over 1.5 million dead in Angola and Mozambique.
  • Afghanistan: this was largely a CIA-supported effort to draw the Russians into invading Afghanistan. The goal was to 'bleed the Russians and pillory the Soviets in world opinion' [p. 111]. "The immediate result was a war that devastated Afghanistan, with even worse consequences after the Russians withdrew and Reagan's jihadis [the Taliban] took over. The long-term result was two decades of terror and civil war." [p. 111]
  • India-Pakistan: the terrorist organizations in Afghanistan then helped inflame the conflict between Pakistan and India.
  • Iraq: there was long-standing US support for Saddam Hussein in the Iraq-Iran war.
  • Philippines: Ferdinand Marcos was supported by the US
  • Haiti: Duvalier was supported by the US
  • Romania: Nicolae Ceausescu was supported by the US
  • Indonesia: Suharto was supported by the US
  • Panama: Noriega was supported by the US
  • Uzbekistan: Islam Karimov is supported by the US
  • Turkmenistan: Saparmurat Niyazov is supported by the US
  • Equitorial Guinea: Teodoro Obiang is supported by the US
  • Algeria: supported by the US

All of the above are repressive regimes who regularly resort to torture and terror to maintain control.

The Script: Domestic

  • "The Reagan years saw a continuation of the relatively poor economic performance of the 1970's. Growth overwhelmingly benefited the very rich, unlike the 'golden age' of the fifties and sixties, when it was evenly spread across the population. During the Reagan-Bush years real wages stagnated or declined with benefits; working hours increased; and employers were given free rein to ignore protection for labor organizing. ... It is not easy, under such conditions, to maintain political power. Only one good method is known: inspire fear." [p. 115]
  • "Crime in the US is not very different from other industrial countries. Fear of crime, however, is much higher. The same is true of drugs. ... It is easy for political leaders to use the media to whip up fear of these and other menaces. ... 'the mass media in America have an overwhelming tendency to jump up and down and bark in concert whenever the White House - any White House - snaps its fingers.' " [p. 117]
  • By spending huge amounts on the military, and by also offering tax cuts ("overwhelmingly benefiting the very rich") the government created a large deficit, which then became an argument for "fiscal discipline" which meant cutting social programs such as Medicare and Social Security. ... "The problem is deepened by the serious financial crisis of states and cities." [p. 119]
  • "If working people depend on the stock market for their pensions, health care, and other means of survival, they have a stake in undrmining their own interests: opposing wage increases, health and safety regulations, and other measures that might cut into profits." [p. 120]
  • "... the classic modern strategy of an endangered right-wing oligarchy, which is to divert mass discontent into nationalism." [p. 120]

Insignificant Risks

  • "... though planners of course do not welcome the proliferation of WMD and terrorism, they know that they can exploit such developments for their own purposes, both global and domestic. Even the fear they elicit throughout the world is quite acceptable: they are not trying to be loved, but obeyed, and if this is achieved by fear, that is fine..." [p. 125]
  • "Maintaining a hold on political power and enhancing US control of the world's primary energy sources are major steps toward the twin goals that have been declared with considerable clarity: to institutionalize a radical restructuring of domestic society that will roll back the progressive reforms of a century, and to establish an imperial grand staraategy of permanent world domination." [p. 125]

The Wild Men in the Wings

  • "There was little discussion of the possible effects of war on the population of Iraq." [p. 125]
  • "With the Iraqi people at the edge of survival after a decade of destructive sanctions, international aid and medical agencies warned that a war might lead to a serious humanitarian catastrophe." [p. 126]
  • "... the sanctions devastated the population while strengthening Saddam Hussein and his clique, alos increasing the dependency of the Iraqi people on the tyrant for their survival." [p. 127]
  • " 'Studied lack of interest' in the likely consequences of war for the population of the country to be invaded is conventional." [p. 128]
  • "... it is the range of likely possibilities that determines the evaluation of policy choices that are made, at least for those capable of entertaining elementary moral standards." [p. 129]

Democracy and Human Rights

  • "... lofty rhetoric is the obligatory accompanyment of virtually any resort to force and therefore carries no information." [p. 129]
  • "In the two major European countries, Germany and France, the official government stands corresponded to the views of the large majority of their populations, which unequivocally opposed the war." [p. 131]
  • "Turks despised Saddam Hussein but did not fear him. They also strongly opposed the war. ... While popular opinion apparently turned even more strongly against the war, the government finally yielded to severe US economic and other coercion, and agreed to comply with Washington's demands over 'overwhelming' popular opposition. ... In the end, the Turks proceeded to teach a lesson in democracy to the West. Parliament finally refused to allow US troops to be deployed fully in Turkey." [p. 134 - 135]
  • In the US, "public opinion studies which reveal that on the eve of the election, three-quarters of the population regarded it as a game played by large contributors, party leaders, and the PR industry, which crafted candidates to say 'almost anything to get themselves elected' ... "voters were directed to 'personal qualities', not 'issues' " [p. 139]
  • "What remains of democracy is largely the right to choose among commodities. Business leaders have long explained the need to impose on the population a 'philosophy of futility' and 'lack of purpose in life', to 'concentrate human attention on the more superficial things that comprise much of fashionable consumption.' Deluged by such propaganda from infancy, people may then accept their meaningless and subordinate lives and forget ridiculous ideas about managing their own affairs. They may aboandon their fate to corporate managers and the PR industry and, in the political realm, to the self-described 'intelligent minorities' who seve and administer power." [p. 139]

While I am aware of the "war" in Angola, I had no idea that the casualties were as large as Chomsky claims. Back to google:

http://www.geocities.com/Yosemite/Forest/1771/raid1.htm

http://www.onwar.com/aced/nation/all/angola/fangola1975.htm

Yes, the figures seem to be similar.

This has been an enjoyable two hours, even if the topic is depressing. Chomsky ends with a prophetic sentence: "That is of course a choice, one that is very largely in the hands of the American people." [p. 143] The election is less than a week away.


Reminder: each "Learning" session has a new web page.

Last Page
Next Page

History Index